skip to Main Content
What Is A “Will Contest”?

What is a “Will Contest”?

In New York State, before a Will is deemed a valid instrument by a Court, generally , it must be “probated” (latin for prove). Prior to the Will’s admittance to probate, certain persons with an interest in the estate of a deceased person are required to be formally notified of the probate proceeding. These persons often include the decedent’s children, siblings, spouse, and certain other persons who would be adversely affected if the Will were admitted to probate.

If one of these persons objects to the validity of the Will because their interest in property or in the estate of the decedent would be adversely affected by the admission of the Will to probate, they will be given an opportunity to examine, under oath, the attorney who drafted the purported Will, and the persons who witnessed the Will execution ceremony. If still not satisfied that the Will is a valid instrument, an adversely affected person can interpose objections to probate of the Will by filing a document with the Court called “Objections to Probate”.

The six most common objections one makes to probate of a purported Will are:

Lack of Due Execution

The statutory formalities were not followed during the Will execution ceremony.

Lack of Testamentary Capacity

The person who made the purported Will, called a “testator” or “testatrix”, did not have the requisite mental capacity to execute the purported Will.

Undue Influence

Undue influence is defined as a moral coercion which restrained independent action and destroyed free agency, which constrained the testator or testatrix to do that which was against his or her free will and desire, which he or she was unable to refuse or too weak to resist.

Fraud

In order to state a claim for fraud, an objectant must demonstrate that the person accused of such fraud knowingly made a false statement to the testator or testatrix that caused him or her to execute a Will that disposed of his or her property in a manner differently than he or she would have in the absence of that statement.

Duress

A donative transfer is procured by duress if the wrongdoer threatened to perform or did perform a wrongful act that coerced the donor into making a donative transfer that the donor would not otherwise have made.

Mistake

One common example: There is a drafting error by the attorney, and the purported instrument does not really speak the testator or testatrix’s true “will”. Daniel J. Reiter, Esq.’s article on this topic is published in the New York State Bar Association Trusts and Estates Law Section Newsletter.

Daniel J. Reiter, Esq. handles all aspects of Will contests and estate litigation. Mr. Reiter also counsels clients in the area of “defensive” estate planning in order to avoid will contests and other forms of litigation and disruption during probate and administration of a decedent’s estate.

If you have questions about a Will you believe is invalid or wish to engage in defensive estate planning, you are encouraged to contact me at 646-820-4011 or djr@djrattorney.com.

Daniel J. Reiter, Esq.

Daniel J. Reiter is an attorney admitted to practice in New York. Mr. Reiter focuses in the areas of estate and trust litigation, non-routine Surrogate’s Court work, adult guardianship and mental health law, power of attorney litigation, and civil litigation and dispute resolution. He also routinely practices in the areas of estate planning, elder law, and Medicaid.

Back To Top